11th Circuit Court Rules Against ObamaCare

A federal court in Atlanta ruled On Friday that the health care reform law’s insurance requirement is unconstitutional, delivering the Obama administration’s signature piece of legislation its first blow at the appellate court level.

The three-judge panel in the 11th U.S. Circuit of Appeals in Atlanta ruled 2-1 against the insurance requirement. It is the first appellate court to find the insurance requirement violates the constitution.

Chief Judge Joel Dubina and Circuit Judge Frank Hull wrote that “the individual mandate contained in the act exceeds Congress’s enumerated commerce power.” Circuit Judge Stanley Marcus dissented.

A federal appeals court in Cincinnati upheld the law’s insurance mandate in June. Another appellate case is pending at a court in Richmond, Va.

The Atlanta judges ruled against invalidating the entire law, instead finding the law could stand without the insurance coverage requirement. That is a small victory for the administration.

via 11th Circuit Court Rules Against Obama’s Health Care Law  | Iron Mill News Service.

Appeals court in Atlanta hears states’ case against health care law

ATLANTA – The debate over President Obama’s healthcare reform law is so emotionally charged that competing protestors challenged each other on the sidewalk outside Atlanta’s U.S. 11 Circuit Court of Appeals Court on Wednesday.

Inside, a three judge panel heard formal arguments over Florida U.S. District Judge Roger Vinson’s earlier ruling that the 2010 law is unconstitutional.

Right off the bat, Chief Judge Joel Dubina questioned the Federal government’s assertion that it has a right to require Americans to buy health insurance by 2014.

“If we uphold the individual mandates in this case are there any limits on the power of Congress?” asked Dubina.

Acting U.S. Solicitor General Neal Katyal justified the mandate to shift the burden of paying medical costs for 50-million uninsured citizens.

Speaking on behalf of 26 states who want to overturn the law, former U.S. Solicitor Paul Clement argued that in 220 years Congress never saw fit to pass a law that required Americans to buy anything.

“It strikes me that this is really about individual liberty,” said Judge Stanley Marcus.

via Appeals court in Atlanta hears states’ case against health care law | 11alive.com.

About the Author

Politisite delivers the latest Breaking Political News, Debate Coverage, Election Results, Commentary and Analysis. We provide in-depth news with special reports and interactive political coverage. Politisite was a pioneer in internet political news gathering and dissemination. Politisite came live in early 1998 and become the first internet only news source to cover local, state, and national political campaigns, debates and elections. Before there were the terms Blog, Blogger, New Media, or Crowd-sourcing, Politisite was developing what has become the standard in political news coverage, long before most political sites were even conceived. The Name ‘Politisite” simply means Political Website.

Author Archive Page

Post a Comment