The Left wonders if Supreme Court Nominee is Qualified to replace Stevens

Some left leaners are already questioning if Supreme Court Nominee Elana Kagan is qualified to replace Justice Stevens.  Some are aligning Kagan with Bush Nominee Harriet Miers. Bush touted Miers as a “you have to trust me on this” nominee.  The Wall  Street Journal put it this way:

“I think the problem many liberals have is that they’re heading largely into the unknown with Kagan at a time when, with 59 senators and a tradition of following the president’s lead on matters of the Supreme Court, a more definitive choice could have been made,” writes David Dayen for the liberal blog FireDogLake.

Glenn Greenwald at Salon takes a sharper tone against Kagan, casting her as a “blank slate, institution-loyal, seemingly principle-free careerist.”

Paul Campos, who earlier aligned Kagan to former President George W. Bush’s ill-fated nomination of Harriet Miers to the high court, reiterates that message today for the Daily Beast. “The argument for Miers came down to the claim that conservatives should simply trust George W. Bush to make these kinds of decisions. This is exactly the same argument that political progressives are now being asked to accept in regard to Kagan: that they should trust Barack Obama.”

The early criticism of Kagan is notable for a couple of reasons: It might affect the confirmation process, and it signals how her nomination might do little to excite the party’s progressive base just ahead of the midterm elections.

via The Left Leans Against Kagan – Washington Wire – WSJ.

Related:

Elena Kagan Nominated To Supreme Court

Obama’s natural choice of Kagan

Kagan Doesn’t Deserve It

About Albert N. Milliron 6987 Articles
Albert Milliron is the founder of Politisite. Milliron has been credentialed by most major news networks for Presidential debates and major Political Parties for political event coverage. Albert maintains relationships with the White House and State Department to provide direct reporting from the Administration’s Press team. Albert is the former Public Relations Chairman of the Columbia County Republican Party in Georgia. He is a former Delegate. Milliron is a veteran of the US Army Medical Department and worked for Department of Veterans Affairs, Department of Psychiatry.

1 Trackback / Pingback

  1. Tweets that mention The #Left wonders if Supreme Court Nominee is #Qualified to replace Stevens: Some left… #tcot -- Topsy.com